How to prove formally that division is not commutative?

by Alvise Sembenico   Last Updated March 14, 2019 20:20 PM

I am studying quantitative reasoning and I am wondering how to prove formally that division is not commutative. Everyone knows that 7/3 is not the same as 3/7, but is there a formal way to conceptualize it? Thank you



Answers 2


Asserting that $\frac73\neq\frac37$ is a full proof of the fact that division is not commutative. A simpler proof would be the fact that $\frac21\neq\frac12$.

José Carlos Santos
José Carlos Santos
March 14, 2019 19:53 PM

Let us define $$\frac{a}{b}:=a b^{-1}$$ for $b\neq0$ and $a\neq bk$ for any $k\in\Bbb Z$. Here, $b^{-1}$ just denotes the element that produces unity upon multiplication by $b$ (stated succinctly, $b\cdot b^{-1}=1$). Since $ab^{-1}\neq a^{-1}b$, we have that division is not commutative. Indeed, $$ab^{-1}=a^{-1}b\Longrightarrow (ab^{-1})^2=1\Longrightarrow a=\pm b,$$which is a contradiction to our assumption that $a\neq bk$. We have used the commutative property of multiplication here.

An alternative, but essentially equivalent method: if $ab^{-1}=a^{-1}b$, then we have $a^2=b^2$. Now all we need to do is to demonstrate a pair of elements $a,b$ whose squares are not equal; in particular, $3^2=9\neq 49=7^2$, so $\frac 37\neq\frac73$.

Clayton
Clayton
March 14, 2019 20:07 PM

Related Questions


Updated May 19, 2017 22:20 PM

Updated July 07, 2018 15:20 PM

Updated March 06, 2019 16:20 PM